404 errors, indicating that a webpage is not found, are a natural part of any website's lifecycle, especially as content evolves, pages are removed, and URLs change. However, an excessive number of 404 errors can significantly harm your website's SEO.

Negative Impacts of Many 404 Pages on SEO

1. Poor User Experience

Frustration and Exit Rates

  • User Frustration: When users encounter a 404 page, they are often frustrated because they cannot find the information they were seeking. This negative experience can lead them to leave your site immediately.
  • High Bounce Rates: Frequent 404 errors can lead to higher bounce rates. If users consistently encounter 404 errors, they are more likely to leave your site without visiting other pages.

Loss of Trust

  • Perceived Unreliability: A high number of 404 errors can make your website seem unreliable or poorly maintained, damaging your credibility and trust with visitors.
  • Brand Perception: Negative user experiences can lead to a poor perception of your brand, affecting not only immediate interactions but also long-term brand loyalty.

2. Crawl Budget Waste

Inefficient Crawling

  • Search Engine Crawlers: Search engines allocate a specific crawl budget to each site, which is the number of pages they will crawl during a given period.
  • Wasted Resources: If search engine bots spend a significant portion of their crawl budget on 404 pages, they waste resources that could have been used to discover and index new or updated content.

Delayed Indexing

  • Impact on New Content: With a crawl budget wasted on 404 errors, new or updated content may take longer to be discovered and indexed by search engines, delaying its appearance in search results.

Lost Link Value

  • Broken Links: If external sites link to a page on your site that returns a 404 error, the link equity or "link juice" from those backlinks is lost.
  • Impact on SEO: Quality backlinks are a significant factor in search engine rankings. Losing link equity due to 404 errors can negatively impact your site's overall SEO performance.

Internal Linking Issues

  • Broken Internal Links: Internal links leading to 404 pages disrupt the user journey and can prevent search engines from effectively crawling and indexing your site.
  • Site Structure: An effective internal linking structure helps search engines understand the hierarchy and relationship between different pages. Broken links weaken this structure.

Strategies to Mitigate 404 Errors

1. Regular Monitoring and Fixing

Use Google Search Console

  • Error Reports: Regularly check Google Search Console for crawl errors and 404 reports. This tool provides detailed information on where and why 404 errors occur.
  • Timely Fixes: Address these errors promptly to minimize their impact on SEO.

Crawl Your Site

  • SEO Tools: Use tools like Screaming Frog, Ahrefs, or SEMrush to crawl your site and identify 404 errors.
  • Comprehensive Audits: Perform regular site audits to ensure all pages are accessible and to fix broken links.

2. Implement 301 Redirects

Permanent Redirects

  • 301 Redirects: Use 301 redirects to permanently redirect traffic from a deleted or moved page to a relevant new page. This helps preserve link equity and provide a seamless user experience.
  • Automatic Redirects: Implement automated systems for setting up redirects whenever you remove or change URLs.

Redirect Chains

  • Avoid Chains: Ensure that 301 redirects do not lead to other redirects (redirect chains), as this can slow down crawling and reduce link equity transfer.
  • Direct Paths: Redirect users and search engines directly to the final destination page.

3. Optimize 404 Pages

User-Friendly Design

  • Custom 404 Page: Design a custom 404 page that is helpful and engaging. Include a friendly message, site navigation, search bar, and links to popular or relevant pages. You can customize your 404 page from the Shopify Theme Editor.
  • Encourage Exploration: Provide suggestions for what users can do next, reducing the likelihood of them leaving your site.

SEO Considerations

  • Noindex Tag: Use the "noindex" tag on 404 pages to prevent search engines from indexing them, ensuring they don’t appear in search results.
  • Tracking: Use analytics tools to track the performance of your 404 pages and understand how users interact with them.

Final Thoughts

While 404 errors are an inevitable part of managing a website, an excessive number can harm your SEO by frustrating users, wasting crawl budget, and losing valuable link equity. Regularly monitoring and fixing 404 errors, implementing 301 redirects, and optimizing 404 pages are crucial steps in mitigating their negative impact. By addressing these issues proactively, you can maintain a healthier site structure, improve user experience, and enhance your overall SEO performance.

Share this article